The Box Review
PLOT: A small wooden box arrives on the doorstep of a married couple, who know that opening it will grant them a million dollars and kill someone they don't know.
THE GOOD: Idea. You have to admit that the plot of The Box is quite gripping. Based on the 1970 short story Button, Button by Richard Matheson, The Box is a story about greed, desperation, and sacrifice. There's a lot of mystery in the story. It reminded me of what makes Lost so great.

Intriguing. The mystery made the movie fun for me. I never found myself bored or realizing I was watching a slow scene. My mind was constantly trying to figure out what was going on. I could probably watch this one or two more times.
Music. Win Butler, Régine Chassagne, and Owen Pallett of Canadian band Arcade Fire provided an original score for the film. It's dark and enigmatic just like the film. It reminded me a lot of the old Twilight Zone episodes. Added to the drama and tension in the film.
THE BAD: Story. About 1/3 of the way in, the movie takes a turn into strange. Strange becomes silly, silly becomes absurd, and absurd becomes "Oh, come on!". The moral dilemma in the film really isn't as important as it should be.

Richard Kelly. He is his own worst enemy. Writer-director Richard Kelly starts out with a strong premise and you can tell that he really puts a lot of thought into the movie. It's something I admire about the guy. Look at Donnie Darko and the research he put into time travel. With The Box, he introduces us to an interesting subject matter, but quickly takes us to another one with barely any explanation. It looks like what I think ADD feels like. That's certainly how I would describe Southland Tales as well, except that wasn't even remotely intriguing.
THE END: In one sentence, The Box is completely ridiculous, but interesting. It's not quite as scattered as Southland Tales, but it doesn't have the aliveness of Donnie Darko. If there's anything that Richard Kelly does right, it's his research. Kelly needs to remember how to put that research into a story that's at least a little more plausible. Easily not worth seeing in theatres, and a maybe on renting.
DISCUSS: What did you think of Donnie Darko? How would you have changed the story for The Box? Did you guess what would happen in the movie? How did you feel about the ending?
























































